When you step into Carrabba’s Italian Grill, you’re not just entering a restaurant you’re stepping into a world of warmth, flavor, and tradition. From the aroma of freshly made pasta to the sound of laughter over shared plates, Carrabba’s captures the soul of Italian hospitality. But beyond its celebrated cuisine lies another hidden treasure: the Carrabba’s Cocktail Menu a curated collection of handcrafted drinks that elevate the dining experience.
Each cocktail tells its own story of Italy, of craft, and of celebration. Whether it’s the Pomegranate Martini, the vibrant Sicilian Prickly Pear Margarita, or the zesty Sparkling Tuscan Lemonade, Carrabba’s cocktails combine the best of Italian-inspired ingredients with modern mixology.
And while these Specialty Cocktails are available for dine-in only, they are worth every sip crafted to complement Carrabba’s signature dishes and transport guests straight to a Tuscan evening.
Carrabba’s Specialty Cocktails Menu
Below is a quick overview of Carrabba’s handcrafted Cocktail Menu offerings where every drink is designed with balance, flavor, and freshness in mind.
| Cocktail | Price | Calories |
| Pomegranate Martini | $10.99 | 200 cal |
| Sicilian Prickly Pear Margarita | $10.49 | 280 cal |
| Sangria-Rita | $10.49 | 240 cal |
| Italian Old Fashioned | $10.99 | 170 cal |
| Sparkling Tuscan Lemonade | $10.49 | 190 cal |
Each cocktail is made-to-order by Carrabba’s Cocktail Menu skilled bartenders delivering the perfect balance between flavor, aroma, and presentation. Let’s explore each in detail.
1. Pomegranate Martini $10.99 | 200 cal
Elegant, crisp, and refreshing, the Pomegranate Martini is one of Carrabba’s Cocktail Menu most sophisticated drinks. It combines the tart sweetness of pomegranate with the smooth bite of premium vodka, resulting in a cocktail that’s both modern and timeless.
Flavor Profile:
A beautiful mix of sweet, tart, and slightly citrusy balanced perfectly with a smooth, icy finish.
Ingredients (Inspired Recreation):
- Absolut Citron Vodka
- Pomegranate Juice
- Orange Liqueur (like Cointreau or Triple Sec)
- Fresh Lemon Juice
- Simple Syrup
Shaken over ice and strained into a chilled martini glass, the drink glows with a ruby hue garnished with a twist of lemon or a few pomegranate seeds.
Best Pairings:
- Chicken Bryan: The tangy goat cheese and sun-dried tomato sauce pair beautifully with the martini’s fruity tartness.
- Seafood Dishes: Especially shrimp or scallops, as the acidity enhances delicate flavors.
Why It’s Special:
This martini captures the spirit of Italian aperitivo culture elegant, bright, and designed to awaken your palate before the meal.
2. Sicilian Prickly Pear Margarita $10.49 280 cal
A showstopper on the Carrabba’s menu, the Sicilian Prickly Pear Margarita is vibrant, colorful, and bursting with life just like Sicily itself. It’s a fusion of Mexican tradition and Italian flair, featuring the exotic sweetness of prickly pear fruit balanced with the tang of lime and the smoothness of tequila.
Flavor Profile:
Sweet, tangy, and citrusy with a subtly floral note from the prickly pear.
Inspired Ingredients:
- Tequila
- Triple Sec or Orange Liqueur
- Fresh Lime Juice
- Prickly Pear Syrup or Purée
- Salted Rim (optional)
Served over ice in a margarita glass, this cocktail’s Cocktail Menu deep magenta hue makes it visually stunning.
Best Pairings:
- Chicken Marsala: The fruity acidity cuts through the rich mushroom sauce.
- Tuscan-Grilled Ribeye: Offers a refreshing counterpoint to bold, smoky flavors.
Why It’s Special:
This cocktail embodies Carrabba’s Cocktail Menu creativity combining global inspirations with a distinctly Italian personality. It’s a perfect choice for guests who want something adventurous yet perfectly balanced.
3. Sangria-Rita $10.49 240 cal
The Sangria-Rita is Carrabba’s Cocktail Menu playful twist on two beloved drinks the Spanish sangria and the Mexican margarita. It brings together the best of both worlds: fruity red wine flavors layered over a tangy margarita base.
Flavor Profile:
Fruity, bold, and slightly tangy with notes of citrus, berries, and orange.
Inspired Cocktail Menu Ingredients:
- Tequila
- Red Sangria (Carrabba’s house blend)
- Orange Liqueur
- Lime Juice
- Splash of Soda or Sprite
This layered cocktail is as beautiful as it is delicious. The sangria gives it richness, while the margarita adds zest creating a dynamic flavor experience.
Best Pairings:
- Pasta Dishes: Especially creamy Alfredo or tomato-based pastas.
- Appetizers: Try it with Mozzarella Marinara or Meatballs & Ricotta.
Why It’s Special:
It’s the perfect “fun” Cocktail Menu festive, colorful, and brimming with Mediterranean character. Guests love its balanced sweetness and refreshing finish.
4. Italian Old Fashioned $10.99 170 cal
A true masterpiece for whiskey lovers, the Italian Old Fashioned reimagines the American classic with an Italian touch. Rich, aromatic, and deeply satisfying, this drink blends bourbon with Italian liqueurs to create a bold, smooth sip.
Flavor Profile:
Warm, oaky, and slightly sweet with hints of citrus and almond.
Inspired Cocktail Menu Ingredients:
- Bourbon Whiskey
- Amaretto (Italian almond liqueur)
- Orange Peel
- Bitters
- Luxardo Cherry for garnish
The Amaretto adds a nutty sweetness that sets this version apart from the traditional Old Fashioned, making it smoother and more refined.
Best Pairings:
- Steak Marsala: The bold whiskey notes complement the savory mushroom sauce.
- Lasagne or Rigatoni Martino: The caramel and almond tones blend perfectly with rich tomato sauces.
Why It’s Special:
It’s both familiar and exotic a nod to the Italian-American connection that defines Carrabba’s itself. A must-try for those who enjoy spirit-forward Cocktail Menu.
5. Sparkling Tuscan Lemonade $10.49 190 cal
Light, bubbly, and refreshing, the Sparkling Tuscan Lemonade embodies the spirit of the Mediterranean coast. It’s a lemon lover’s dream bright and zesty, with a delicate sparkle that makes it irresistibly refreshing.
Flavor Profile:
Citrusy, effervescent, and lightly sweet with a smooth vodka base.
Inspired Ingredients:
- Absolut Citron Vodka
- Limoncello (Italian lemon liqueur)
- Fresh Lemon Juice
- Simple Syrup
- Sparkling Water or Prosecco
Served over ice with a lemon wheel garnish, it’s perfect for warm days or as a palate cleanser between courses.
Best Cocktail Menu Pairings:
- Seafood: Shrimp Scampi or Salmon Capperi.
- Chicken Piccata: The lemon-on-lemon pairing enhances brightness and flavor.
Why It’s Special:
This cocktail captures everything that defines Carrabba’s freshness, balance, and a touch of Italian sunshine.
Perfect Pairings: Carrabba’s Cocktail Menu Food Meets Cocktail Art
To elevate your dining experience, Carrabba’s Cocktail Menu has carefully designed cocktails that complement their signature dishes. Below is a pairing guide that brings harmony to your meal:
| Cocktail | Perfect Food Pairing | Why It Works |
| Pomegranate Martini | Chicken Bryan | Sweet-tart notes enhance creamy goat cheese and tomato sauce. |
| Sicilian Prickly Pear Margarita | Tuscan-Grilled Ribeye | Refreshing acidity cuts through smoky, rich meat. |
| Sangria-Rita | Fettuccine Alfredo | The fruity flavor balances creamy, buttery textures. |
| Italian Old Fashioned | Lasagne | Deep, bold flavors complement layers of cheese and sauce. |
| Sparkling Tuscan Lemonade | Shrimp Scampi | Citrusy fizz enhances delicate seafood notes. |
The Carrabba’s Cocktail Philosophy
Carrabba’s takes pride in ensuring every cocktail is more than just a drink it’s a crafted experience. Their philosophy combines Italian artistry with modern mixology, focusing on:
- Fresh Ingredients: Citrus juices, herbs, and fruit syrups made daily.
- Balanced Flavors: Sweet, sour, and bitter notes crafted to perfection.
- Authentic Italian Influence: Signature liqueurs like Limoncello and Amaretto.
- Presentation: Every drink is served with care, elegance, and a touch of Italian flair.
This dedication transforms simple ingredients into cocktails that feel both familiar and luxurious.
The Italian Way: Drinks Meant to Be Shared
In Italian culture, cocktails are about more than drinking they’re about connection. The Carrabba’s bar experience embraces that spirit, inviting guests to relax, celebrate, and enjoy life’s simple pleasures.
Whether you’re starting your meal with a crisp Pomegranate Martini or winding down with an Italian Old Fashioned, each drink invites you to slow down and savor the moment.
When to Enjoy Carrabba’s Cocktails
These beverages are ideal for any occasion:
- Pre-Dinner Aperitif: Sparkling Tuscan Lemonade or Pomegranate Martini to awaken your palate.
- Dinner Pairing: Sangria-Rita or Prickly Pear Margarita for balance with savory entrées.
- After-Dinner Drink: Italian Old Fashioned rich and contemplative, perfect with dessert.
Every time you sip, you taste the passion and heritage of Italian dining culture.
What Guests Are Saying
Guests across Carrabba’s locations rave about the Specialty Cocktail Menu:
“The Sicilian Prickly Pear Margarita is my favorite fruity, bright, and gorgeous to look at!”
“The Italian Old Fashioned is smooth and perfectly balanced a classy twist on the original.”
“Carrabba’s Sparkling Tuscan Lemonade is the perfect summer drink. Light, crisp, and delicious.”
These cocktails have become more than drinks they’re part of what makes dining at Carrabba’s a full sensory experience.
The Perfect Finish
From the rich depth of the Italian Old Fashioned to the citrus sparkle of the Tuscan Lemonade, Carrabba’s Specialty Cocktails elevate every meal into a celebration. They reflect the restaurant’s dedication to craft, authenticity, and the joy of gathering the same values that make Carrabba’s Italian Grill a beloved dining destination.
Whether you’re toasting to a special occasion or simply savoring a meal with friends, these handcrafted cocktails add the perfect finishing touch.
Raise your glass, savor the moment, and let Carrabba’s remind you that life like a great cocktail is best enjoyed one sip at a time.
